Don’t bother googling. There are way too many articles out there titled something like: “5 BEST BICEPS EXERCISES” “10…” “15…” Can we get 20? Yes! No joke, that’s really a thing, in Men’s Health: “20 BEST BICEPS EXERCISES.” The difference between this article and all of those is this won’t be a random cluster of every kind of curl. Instead, we’ve got the research. The activation of the biceps during exercises on those lengthy lists has been measured, and, forget all that clickbait that failed to deliver, we’re going to tell you which one truly is the best.
First, some physics and a little geometry. When doing any full-length, free-weight curl, gravity fights to pull the weight straight down to the floor, but, complicating things, your hands (and the weight) travel in an arc. Its only when your forearms are parallel to the floor on each rep that gravity exerts its maximum pull and thus your biceps toil their hardest.
Let’s take this a step further with a clock illustration. We’ll use color zones to simplify (biceps activation would actually be progressive throughout). The center is your elbow joint. The minute hand is your forearm, and it starts pointed straight down to 6:00. Your forearm goes through about a 130-degree range of motion during any full curl rep, so it finishes pointed a little past 10:00. (If you could fold your arms in two, activation on the top of our illustration would mirror the bottom .)
The bottom half of reps (to 8:05) is a breeze. The tops of reps are getting easier as you reach contraction (10:10), so you’re unlikely to fail there. It’s the red zone (8:20 to 9:40), especially the parallel crimson (9:00), where reps go to die.
The American Council of Exercise published a study in which eight young men and eight young women performed eight biceps exercises while the muscle activity of their biceps, anterior deltoids, and brachioradialis were monitored via electrodes and an EMG machine. Results were measured against that person’s maximum voluntary contraction (MVC). And the grades are…
THE CLEAR WINNER
As its name almost demands, the concentration curl allows you to focus on one biceps from rep start to rep finish. Bracing the back of your elbow against your inner thigh prevents cheating, but this exercise’s greatest advantage is that you can easily squeeze contractions, perhaps expanding the red zone all the way to the end. An earlier EMG study also ranked the concentration curl No. 1 (and was especially positive about the negative concentration curl). Many people think of this as a light, pumping move, easy to leave out as you pummel your bi’s with heavy EZ-bar and dumbbell curls, but this is one you shouldn’t skip.
One caveat: This test measured muscle activation. There are other considerations, especially progressive resistance, which is easier to achieve with a heavier, two-arm exercise. For example, advancing from a 25 lb. dumbbell to a 30 lb. dumbbell for 10 reps of concentration curls is a big 20% leap. But going from a 100 lb. barbell curl to 105 lbs., both for 10 reps, is only a 5% advance, or, to better compare it to the concentration curl, 10% per arm. This is a good reason to do at least two, distinctly different types of curls in your biceps routine.
It’s no surprise that the only machine exercise in the test, the cable curl, edged into second. With a weight stack moving vertically, gravity is always pulling, from start to finish. Consider including at least one mechanical exercise in every biceps routine because of its different stress application.
We could’ve also predicted the free-weight preacher curl would lose. Again, it’s all about gravity. By starting each rep 45 degrees forward (the angle of the typical bench), it gets hard fast, the forearm-parallel-to-the-floor red zone comes much sooner, and then it just keeps getting easier. At contractions, your forearm is pretty much perpendicular to the floor (175 degrees) with virtually no gravitational pull.
You can combat this by shortening reps (avoiding contractions) or by attaching chains to the bar to add tension throughout reps (as links come off the floor resistance increases). You can also (spider) curl on the nearly vertical side of the bench. And you can use a handle attached to a cable or a preacher curl machine, both of which feature vertically stacked iron fighting gravity all the while.
But those modifications are different exercises. What about the traditional, free-weight preacher? Should you just drop that loser for good? Nothing flunked this test. The five lowest scoring curls are just a few percentage points apart. All are valuable exercises. The preacher curl, with its unique starting and ending points, hits your bi’s uniquely, focusing more on stretches, less on contractions. People used to think this elongated the biceps. It doesn’t, but you may feel it more in the bottom of your bi’s.
Look again at the photo (by Gene Mozee) at the top of this article. That’s the original Mr. Olympia, Larry Scott, on the left, Freddy Ortiz on the right, O.G. arm-men, circa 1966. They did a hell of a lot of preacher curls. Larry did so many they’re still often called Scott curls. Include the best biceps exercise in your arm routine, but don’t totally scrap the worst one.